Instructions
- Wash all the vegetables and pat them dry so the dressing isn't diluted by excess water.
- Cut the tomatoes into thick wedges directly over a wide, shallow serving plate so their juices collect in the dish — this juice becomes part of the dressing.
- Slice the cucumber into thick half-moons and add to the plate. If the peel is thick or waxy, peel it in alternating stripes for texture and looks.
- Add the green pepper rings and red onion rings, scattering them over the tomatoes and cucumber rather than mixing everything into a uniform toss.
- Scatter the olives over the top.
- Season lightly with sea salt, then drizzle the olive oil evenly over the vegetables, followed by the red wine vinegar.
- Gently turn the vegetables once or twice with a spoon just to coat them — horiatiki should stay loose and chunky, not tossed like a leafy salad.
- Place the whole block (or two thick slabs) of feta on top of the vegetables; do not crumble it.
- Sprinkle the feta and salad with dried oregano, and add a final light drizzle of olive oil over the cheese.
- Serve immediately at room temperature with crusty bread to mop up the juices and oil at the bottom of the plate.
Tips for Success
- Tomatoes make or break this dish: use the ripest, most in-season tomatoes you can find, ideally ones that are slightly soft and fragrant rather than firm supermarket tomatoes bred for shipping.
- Splurge on real Greek extra virgin olive oil — since the dressing is just oil, vinegar, and salt, its flavor carries the whole dish.
- Keep the feta in a slab rather than crumbling it; a good barrel-aged sheep's or sheep-and-goat milk feta holds its shape and gives a creamier bite.
- If raw red onion tastes too sharp, soak the sliced rings in cold water for about 10 minutes and drain before adding.
- Make and serve horiatiki right away — the vegetables are meant to stay crisp, and the salad doesn't keep well once dressed.